Sunday, March 04, 2007

Unter Donner und Blitz

It seems another thrashing of the dead Wiener Philharmoniker horse is making its rounds. (Here and here)

Even your humble author has weighed in on the matter. I'm sorry, but unless the Viennese or Austrian authorities are willing to impose the change by legislation or by funding cuts to the Staatsoper (indirectly forcing the members to comply), there is simply nothing to be done. I might agree with this statement,

A decade after it supposedly committed itself to entering the 21st century, I believe that the Vienna Philharmonic has relinquished its claim to serious consideration as a dynamic cultural organization.

Not, though, because they don't like women at the desks or because they're too conservative. The first is unfortunate and not at all our way of doing things, but - alas - if the Austrian cultural czars were that bothered, they'd do something. Therefore, I conclude they aren't that bothered. The second? Give me a break.

No, I agree simply because I am not sure how in touch they are with the Mitteleuropa tradition with which they are so frequently associated. Their pre-1938 and post-1945 sounds differ; they've worked with a diverse crew of conductors; they've added and (undoubtedly) subtracted from their repertoire. Listen to the famous Bruno Walter recordings, i.e., the big two, and hear the Wiener Philharmoniker that made its name. Listen after 1945, and the voice is still there, just quieter. Ever quieter. To my mind, the tradition of central Europe that made the WP what it is claimed to be was lost or stored in a closet.

Also, the virtuoso American orchestras are proving that they are by no means second-rate. The Chicago Symphony Orchestra, Cleveland Orchestra, and - increasingly - the Los Angeles Philharmonic are showing themselves the equals or betters of their Teutonic colleagues. In fact, I might say that the Wiener Philharmoniker isn't a dynamic cultural force because it isn't conservative enough. It isn't the link to the past that it once was, and it doesn't have a reputation for innovation. They have dined out on the past more than they've actually provided a tangible link with it. If you are going to keep the past alive, you have to live in the past. Not just say, "Well, we have tradition." You have to live that tradition.

For better or for worse. That judgment is, necessarily, left to better minds than mine.

1 Comments:

At 4:54 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

This is a topic that is near to my heart... Many thanks!
Where are your contact details though?

my blog post bodybuilding|supplements|hard gainer|natural weight loss pills|vitamins for weight loss|weight loss vitamins|pills to lose weight|how to gain weight fast|gain weight fast|build muscle lose fat|gain weight pills|weight gaining pills|lose weight pills|exercise programs|natural weight loss|i want to gain weight|best way to gain weight|ways to gain weight fast|weight gaining foods|gaining weight|weight gaining diet|herbal weight loss|gaining weight fast|acai berry diet|pills to gain weight|acai berry weight loss|ways to gain weight|lose weight gain muscle|diet products|need to gain weight|best weight loss product|fastest way to gain weight|diets to gain weight|free weight loss pills|ways to build muscle fast|food to gain weight|i need to gain weight|how do you gain weight|weight gain diets|how to gain weight quickly|weight gain|best ways to gain weight|easy way to gain weight|how to gain weight|easiest way to gain weight|gain weight fast for women|gain weight fast for men|natural weight loss supplements|healthy diet supplements|vegan diet|weight gain fast|trying to gain weight|easy ways to gain weight|workout plan|want to gain weight|quick weight gain|how gain weight fast|weight gain diet|nutrition|gain weight for women|weight gain diet plan|to build muscle fast|fitness tips|weight gaining|build muscle and lose fat|bodybuilding diets|supplement to gain weight|get in shape fast|bodybuilding diet plan|weight gain foods|weight loss tablets|lose fat gain muscle|fast weight gain|foods to gain weight fast|weight gaining tips|how to gain wait fast|how to gain wait|how to put on weight|how to gain weight quick|natural supplements for weight loss|what can i eat to gain weight|how gain weight|how to gain fat|how to maintain weight|fast way to gain weight|foods for weight gain|weight gain tips|lose weight and gain muscle|food for weight gain|how to gain fat fast|weight gain diet for women|natural ways to gain weight|weight gain program|weight gain food|how to gain weight naturally|medicine to gain weight|pills to gain muscle fast|food to gain weight fast|gain weight quickly||acai berry diet|acai berry weight loss|amino acids|best way to gain weight|best ways to gain weight|best weight loss product|body building|bodybuilders|bodybuilding|bodybuilding diet plan|bodybuilding diets|bodyspace|bodyspace app|build muscle|build muscle and lose fat|build muscle lose fat|burn fat|carbohydrates|cardio|creatine|diet products|diets to gain weight|easiest way to gain weight|easy way to gain weight|easy ways to gain weight|exercise|exercise programs|exercises|fast way to gain weight|fast weight gain|fastest way to gain weight|fat burn|fat burners|fat loss|fitness tips|food for weight gain|food to gain weight|food to gain weight fast|foods for weight gain|foods to gain weight fast|free weight loss pills|gain weight fast|gain weight fast for men|gain weight fast for women|gain weight for women|gain weight pills|gain weight quickly|gaining weight|gaining weight fast|get in shape fast|glutamine|hard gainer|healthy diet supplements|herbal weight loss|i want to gain weight

 

Post a Comment

<< Home