Monday, July 17, 2006

Christie's Messiah

Whenever Wilhelm Furtwängler performed Beethoven's 9th, he would throw the finale (the "Seid umschlungen, Millionen..." recapitulation) into a mad tumble. In fact, one gets the sense that the orchestra is holding onto itself, but not by much - and lesser ensembles like the Bayreuther band in '51 don't give one much of that sense. Yes, I am going somewhere with this.

I bought the William Christie and Les Arts Florissants recording of Messiah. I have been on a Baroque kick lately, and I do love this quintessentially English work (despite the fact that it was written by a German). It is a very, very good recording - as is well-known. In fact, I am afraid that this recording will replace Pinnock as my new favorite. A great cast (is there anything Andreas Scholl can't do?), a great band, and a reasonable HIP sensibility contribute to a very sound set.

However, the "Hallelujah" chorus is my point, and my tie-in back to Furtwängler. This is done so fast, and so exuberantly, that one isn't sure upon a first audition that it can sustain itself. Everything is so taut and tightly wound that it seemingly explodes. When the chorus hits the big "King of Kings and Lord of Lords," (d.2; 2:47) it has a feeling that there is actual release and catharsis. While Hogwood, Gardiner, and Pinnock all sort of attack it as though it were already in progress, and Harnoncourt sort of builds up to it, Christie wraps the band ever tighter around his idea, and then lets them explode into the moment.

That is drama. That is what keeps Messiah from being a weird Anglo-Saxon Christmas ritual. Not that the HIP crowd ever gives that sense, but there are only so many times that one can sing that piece without it becoming an odd, and somewhat-stale, ritual.


At 11:48 AM, Blogger AnJaka said...

I like your blogs, I will add your link you to my blog.
This is a resource you can visit :
Google Music Links

And Listen to musics

At 4:00 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

lnux enterprise server ebook garth nix lady friday ebook [url=]network security william stallings ebook[/url] ebook the magician's ward

At 7:07 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

win tariff call accounting software best malware software 2009 [url=]accounting business retail software[/url] wireless wep hacking software
[url=]Netshred X 4.1 [Mac] - Download OEM, Software Sale, OEM Software[/url] pansat 2700 default software download

At 8:12 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

ad-hoc chat software best windows software [url=]action replay software downloads for nds[/url] gps 315 software
[url=]EMCO Network Malware Cleaner 4.1 - Software Store[/url] tailless student software

At 6:32 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

word sorting software optus cable modem software [url=]book keeping free software[/url] panda software free activescan
[url=]Systemes operationnels - Software Store[/url] what is software scheduler

At 11:54 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

outlook mail sharing software golf association software [url=]paintshop database software[/url] p2kmanager software download
[url=]Graphics & Publishing - Software Store[/url] best firewall software 2007

At 8:22 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

pharmacy technician charms health pharmacy drugs medications zolpidem [url=]cornerstone pharmacy[/url]
french pharmacy online bossier city walmart pharmacy [url=]astelin[/url]
rite aid pharmacy mount vernon pharmacys 16509 [url=]mexican pharmacys[/url]
pharmacy compounding from tablets canadian online pharmacy xanax [url=]men s health[/url]

At 7:34 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

no frills fort erie canada pharmacy prices 222s 200 count bottle illinois pharmacy technician [url=]dillons pharmacy in derby kansas[/url]
doughertys pharmacy in dallas mixtra pharmacy [url=]symmetrel[/url]
pharmacy articles about controlled substance act travel pharmacy technician [url=]medication consult faster local pharmacy service fully receive[/url]
belmont pharmacy reidsville sav on pharmacy albertsons [url=]advair diskus[/url]

At 3:04 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

rockwell pharmacy ways to change the field of pharmacy [url=]eerie college of pharmacy[/url]
online licensed us pharmacy insurance pharmacy delivery jobs [url=]pamelor[/url]
nelson pharmacy pillbox pharmacy weston fl [url=]no prescription pharmacy[/url]
prairie store pharmacy byerly pharmacy journal rss feed [url=]levitra[/url]

At 9:01 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

how long to get pharmacy degree canadien pharmacy no prescription required [url=]how do i become a pharmacy technician[/url]
pharmacy diflucan canadian pharmacy school [url=]erectile dysfunction[/url]
pharmacy ground glass bottle cvs pharmacy 24 hours [url=]hoppers pharmacy[/url]
job pharmacy sales kmart pharmacy clinton oklahoma [url=]cymbalta[/url]

At 10:37 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

dating and texting cherry blossom dating agency scams
best free internet dating site [url=]dating cancer males[/url] online dating chatting personals
speed dating event [url=]7 rules for dating my daughter[/url] dating dejting romantiska relationer [url=]nrjtvd[/url] dating seperated women

At 4:20 AM, Blogger te12 said...

ugg outlet
magic jerseys
jimmy choo shoes
pandora jewelry
armani exchange
true religion outlet
indianapolis colts jerseys
jimmy choo sunglasses
ray ban sunglasses
birkenstock outlet

At 11:57 PM, Blogger yanmaneee said...

kyrie 4 shoes
goyard handbags
louboutin outlet
yeezy boost 350
supreme new york
yeezy shoes
yeezy boost 350 v2
balenciaga shoes
coach factory outlet


Post a Comment

<< Home